WEU Colloquy "European Defence and Security Identity" Madrid, 4 May 1998

List of Participants Contents Members of the Assembly Associate Members Associate Partners Observers Secretaries of Political Groups Delegation Secretaries Speakers Chairmen of Defence Committees from national parliaments Chairmen of Foreign Affairs Committees from national parliaments Permanent Representatives to WEU Permanent Representatives to NATO Representatives from Embassies in Madrid Other participants Interpreters Secretariat of the Italian delegation Accompanying Admiral Torrente, Min. Defence, Spain Accompanying Admiral Lopez, AFSOUTH WEU Secretariat NATO Staff

Members of the Assembly President of the Assembly Mr Llus Mara DE PUIG Spain Chairman of the Spanish delegation to WEU Mr Jos Lus LOPEZ HENARES Spain Chairman of the Defence Committee Mr Armand de DECKER Belgium Chairman of the Political Commitee Mr Jacques BAUMEL France Chairman of the Technological and Aerospace Committee Mr Jim MARSHALL United Kingdom Country Committee Mrs Maria Manuela AGUIAR Portugal Technological MM Guiseppe ALEFFI Italy Defence Michel ALLONCLE France Defence Francesco AMORUSO Italy Political Robert ANTRETTER Germany Presidential, Political Francisco ARNAU Spain Technological David ATKINSON UK Presidential, Technological Pierre BEAUFAYS Belgium Defence Vincenzo BIANCHI Italy Political Mrs Lilo BLUNCK Germany Technological MM Imanol BOLINAGA Spain Defence Aldo BRANCATI Italy Political Mario BRUNETTI Italy Technological Luca CANGEMI Italy Budget & Admin. Michael COLVIN UK Defence Tom COX UK Defence Laurie CUNLIFFE UK Technological Francisco de ASSIS Portugal Political Terry DAVIS UK Presidential, Defence Marcel DEBARGE France Defence Stelio DE CAROLIS Italy Defence Dick DEES Netherlands Defence Lino DIANA Italy Technological Agustin DIAZ DE MERA Spain Defence Mrs Josette DURRIEU France Technological Bill ETHERINGTON UK Technological Fabio EVANGELISTI Italy Political Adolfo FERNANDEZ AGUILAR Spain Budgetary Affairs Raymond FORNI France Political Mrs Maria FYFE UK Political MM Pietro GIANNATTASIO Italy Defence Simone GNAGA Italy Political Fernando GONZALEZ-LAXE Spain Technological Lord GRENFELL UK Political Mrs Ana GUIRADO Spain Budget & Admin. MM Ulrich IRMER German Political Pierre JEAMBRUN France Defence Georgios KALOS Greece Political Mrs Eleonora KATSELI Greece Technological Lord KIRKHILL UK Political MM Angelo LAURICELLA Italy Technological Guy LENGAGNE France Defence Carlo LEONI Italy Defence Luciano LORENZI Italy Technological Carlos LUS Portugal Technological Vassilos MAGGINAS Greece Defence Valentino MARTELLI Italy Technological Gnter MARTEN Germany Defence Jos MEDEIROS-FERREIRA Portugal Defence Kevin McNAMARA UK Defence Josef MICHELOYANNIS Greece Defence Lord NEWALL UK Defence MM Edward O'HARA UK Political Rosario OLIVO Italy Technological Mario ONAINDIA Spain Parliamentary & Pub. Rel Paulo PEREIRA COELHO Portugal Defence Paolo POLENTA Italy Defence Viron POLYDORAS Greece Technological Gabino PUCHE RODRIGUEZ Spain Political Mrs Pilar PULGAR FRAILE Spain Parliamentary & Pub. Rel MM Lluis RECODER Spain Political Pedro ROSETA Portugal Political Lord RUSSELL-JOHNSTON UK Defence MM John TOWNEND UK Standing Committee Gustavo SELVA Italy Defence Ioannis SKOULARISIS Greece Political Jordi SOLE TURA Spain Defence Francesco SPERONI Italy Defence Paul STAES Belgium Technological Mrs Vera SQUARCIALUPI Italy Political MM Alphonse THEIS Luxembourg Technological John TOWNEND UK Defence Guiseppe TURINI Italy Technological Robert URBAIN Belgium Political Dirk van der MAELEN Belgium Political vJean VALLEIX France Technological Constantinos VRETTOS Greece Political Kofi YAMGNANE France Political Eisso WOLTJER Netherlands Political Jimmy WRAY UK Policital Benno ZIERER Germany Defence Mrs Rodula ZISSIS Greece Technological Associate Members MM Cerdet AKCALI Turkey Political Abdulbaki ATAC Turkey Political Ali DINCER Turkey Technological Ingvald GODAL Norway Defence Fridtjof GUNDERSEN Norway Presidential, Political Esat KIRATLIOGLU Turkey Defence Atilla MUTMAN Turkey Political Ms Lara Margret RAGNARSDOTTIR Iceland Political MM ssur SKARPHDINSSON Iceland Defence Mehmet SILAY Turkey Political Ismail SUNGUR Turkey Defence Associate Partners Mr Andris AMERIKS Latvia Defence, Technological Mrs Irena BELOHORSK Slovak Rep. Political Czelaw BIELECKI Poland Defence MM Laszlo BOGAR Hungary Technological Ivan GLOUCHKOV Bulgaria Defence Zmago JELINCIC Slovenia Defence Jaromir KALUS Czech Rep. Presidential, Political Libor KUDLACEK Czech Rep. Defence Bronislavas KUZMICKAS Lithuania Political Tiit MADE Estonia Defence Aloydas MEDALINSKAS Lithuania Defence Aap NELJAS Estonia Political, Technological Tone PARTLJIC Slovenia Political Longin PASTUSIAK Poland Political Josef PROKES Slovak Rep. Defence Bogomir SPILETIC Slovenia Technological Kroly SZAB Romania Defence Gabriel TEPELEA Romania Political Vasile VACARU Romania Technological Tadeusz ZIELINSKI Poland Technological Observers MM Anders BJRCK Sweden Defence Peter CHRISTENSEN Denmark Defence Michael FERRIS Ireland Defence & Technological Mrs Anna-Marie HANSEN Denmark Defence & Political Mrs Inga-Britt JOHANSSON Sweden Political Mr Dick ROCHE Ireland Political Secretaries of Political Groups Mrs Marlne ALBANESE + daughter Socialist Group Mr Alexander BARTLING Federated Group of Christian Democrats Mrs Barbara NORD + daughter Federated Group of Christian Democrats Delegation Secretaries Mr Igors AIZSTRAUTS Latvia MM Niels Erik ANDERSEN Denmark Benedetto ARSINI Italy Mrs Eleni KONSTANTINIDO Greece Ms Michaela HORALKOVA Czech Republic Mr Mikolaj KARLOWSKI Poland Mrs Andrea KREBS Germany Mr Mindaugas MECIUS Lithuania Ms Madalina MORARU Romania Mr Mitko NIKOLOV Bulgaria Mrs Ene RONGELEP Estonia MM Marc de ROUCK Belgium Peter VALDNER Slovak Rep. Philippe VINCENT France Speakers Mr Anders BJRCK, Member of Parliament, former Defence Minister, Sweden Mr Jos CUTILEIRO, Secretary-General of WEU Captain Jean DUFOURCQ, International relations, Armed Forces Headquarters, Ministry of Defence, France Mr Przemyslaw GRUDZINSKI, Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Poland Admiral Thomas J. LOPEZ, Commander-in-Chief, AFSOUTH, Naples Admiral Rafael de MORALES, Director of the WEU Planning Cell, Brussels General Manuel OLIVER, First Deputy to the Commander, European Corps, Strasbourg Mr Stelios PERRAKIS, Secretary General, European Affairs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Greece General Jean-Paul RAFFENNE, Deputy, Under Chief-of-Staff for international relations, Armed Forces Headquarters, Ministry of Defence, France Mr Heinrich RENTMEISTER, Deputy Director of the Planning Department, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Germany Mr Petre ROMAN, President of the Romanian Senate, Romania Mr Eduardo SERRA, Minister for Defence of Spain Mr Javier SOLANA MADARIAGA, Secretary General of NATO Admiral Francisco TORRENTE, Director General for Defence Policy, Ministry of Defence, Spain Mr Akis TSOHATZOPOULOS, Minister for Defence of Greece Mr Federico TRILLO-FIGUEROA, President of the Spanish Chamber of Deputies H.E. Mr Alexander VERSHBOW, Permanent Representative of the United States to NATO Mr Rob de WIJK, Clingendael Institute, Netherlands Chairmen of Defence Committees from national parliaments MM Imrich ANDREJCAK Slovak Republic Nicolae ALEXANDRU Romania Hans ENGELL Denmark Algirdas KATKUS Lithuania Ioan MIRCEA PASCU Romania Eduardo RIBEIRO PEREIRA Portugal Rudolf PETAN Slovenia Eino TAMM Estonia Chairmen of Foreign Affairs Committees from national parliaments MM Czeslaw BIELECKI Poland (and member of the Assembly) Victor BOSTINARU Romania Austin DEASY Ireland (Vice-Chairman) + Mr Brian HICKEY (secretary) Mrs Helle DEGN Denmark MM Jelko KACIN Slovenia Nikolay KAMOV Bulgaria (Deputy Chairman) Manfred Mautner MARKHOF Austria Ghiorghi PRISACARU Romania Dusan SLOBODNIK Slovak Republic Eisso WOLTJER Netherlands (and member of the Assembly) Permanent Representatives to WEU H.E. Mr Jorge FUENTES MONZONIS, Spain Permanent Representatives to NATO H.E. Mr Antonio MARTINS DA CRUZ, Portugal H.E. Mr Javier CONDE DE SARO, Spain Representatives from Embassies in Madrid M. Franois BONTEMPS, Secrtaire , Belgique Mr Dusan CHRENEK, Second Secretary, Slovak Republic S.E. Monsieur Xavier DUMOULIN, Ambassadeur, Belgique Lt. Colonel EMG William GARGIULLO, Attach de dfense adjoint, Suisse Mr Dmitri KAZIMIROV, First Counsellor, Russia Mr K. van KESTEREN, Minister Counsellor, Netherlands H.E. Mr Victor Gueorguievich KOMPLEKTOV, Ambassador, Russia H.E. Mr Patrick LECLERCQ, Ambassador, France Mr Dmitri LOBATCH, Russia H.E. Mr Leonardo MATHIAS, Ambassador, Portugal Mr Mario MATOS, Minister Counsellor, Portugal H.E. Mr Olgerts R. PAVLOVSKIS, Ambassador, Latvia Mr Mihail ROSIANU, Minister Counsellor, Romania H.E. Mr Stanislav I. SIMONCIC, Ambassador, Slovak Republic Mr Nicolai SOFINSKI, Minister Counsellor, Russia Mr Gazne SOYSAL, Minister Counsellor, Turkey H.E. Mr Olexander TARANENKO, Ambassador, Ukraine + rep. from German embassy + rep. from Italian embassy Other participants Mr Nuno AGUIRRE de CRCER Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Felix ARTEAGA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Jos Luis ANDRES MARTIN NATO/WEU relations unit, Ministry of Defence, Madrid Ms. Paloma ARANA KNIRSCH Experto en Seguridad Europea Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mrs Elisabeth BAARVELD-SCHLAMAN + spouse Senator, Former member of the WEU Assembly, The Hague, Netherlands Mme Anna BALLETBO PUIG Dput, Secrtaire gnrale Fondacio Olof Palme, Barcelona M. Joel BARBIER Conseiller du Directeur, Charg des affaires et relations Europens, Arospatiale, Bruxelles Mr Gonzalo de BENITO Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Augusto BORDERAS Senator, Former member of the Assembly, Member of the Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid M. Roland BORER Conseiller national, Membre de la Commission de la politique de scurit du Conseil National, Parlement suisse, Berne M. Pierre-Yves BREULEUX Secrtaire des Commissions de la politique de scurit du Conseil des Etats et du Conseil National, Parlement suisse, Berne Mr Carlos BRUQUETAS Director, Instituto Ciencia y Sociedad, Madrid Mr Jos Luis BUHIGAS Consultor Comunitario Danube-Holdings, Madrid Mr Mugur BUJE Chief of Cabinet of the President of the Senate of Romania, Bucharest Mr Jos Miguel CARDENAS HERNANDEZ NATO/WEU relations unit, Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mr Antonio de CARVAJAL Director de Tecnologia y Calidad, Grupo Indra, Spain Member of the Board of the European Defence Industries Group (EDIG), Brussels Mrs Maria Jesus CASTRO MATEOS, Senador, Comisin de Defensa del Senado, Madrid Mr Gonzalo CEBALLOS II Secretary General, Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Enrique COBO FERNANDEZ Senator, Spanish Senate, Madrid Mr Manuel COMA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid M. Didier COMPARD + spouse Charg de mission, Coopration transatlantique et Europenne, Arospatiale, France M. Raymond COUTURIER, BPE Arospatiale, Espagne Mr Ignacio DIEZ Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Juan DURN-LORIGA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Willem van EEKELEN Senator, former Secretary-General of WEU The Hague, Netherlands Mrs Pilar ERICE URRETA Experto en Seguridad Europea Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mrs Leticia ESCARDO Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Juan M. ESPARZA Special Adviser to the Chief of Defence Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mr Rafael ESTRELLA Vice-President and Chairman of the Defence and Security Committee, North Atlantic Assembly, Brussels Mr Manuel FERNANDEZ MORICHE Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Ms. Katerina FIALKOVA Deputy Director, Security Policy department, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Czech Republic Mr Gabriel ELORRIAGA FERNANDEZ Senador, Portavoz du groupe populaire de la Comisin de Defensa del Senado, Madrid Mrs Elena GARCIA-ALCANIZ Mr Vicente GARRIDO Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Javier GARRIGUES FLOREZ Director General de Seguridad y Desarme, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Member of Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Jos Felix GONZALEZ NORIEGA I Secretario General, Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Manuel GUILLERMO VARELA, Senador, Portavoz Grupo Socialista de la Comisin de Defensa del Senado, Delegacion espanola en la Ass. Atlantico Norte, Madrid M. Arnaud JACOMET Chef de la Section Affaires gnrales Secrtariat Gnral de l'UEO, Bruxelles Mr Rudy DE JAEGER Defence Planning and Operations, NATO HQ Mr Aleksi HRKNEN Director, Security Policy Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Finland Mr Jos Luis HERNAN GOMEZ DE MATEO Experto en Seguridad Europea Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mr Jos F. HERRERA Deputy, Member of the Defence Committee of the Spanish Parliament, Madrid Mr Jesus HIDALGO Tesorero, Asociacin Atlntica espaola, Madrid Mr Enrique HORCAJADA SCHWARTZ NATO/WEU relations unit, Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mr Juan JACOB CALVO Professor Universidad Barcelona, Fundacion Internacional Olof Palme, Barcelona Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Rastislav KACER Director, Department of Analysis and Policy Planning, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Slovak Republic Mr Nikolay KAMOV Vice-Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Policy and European integration, National Assembly, Bulgaria Mrs Lise KELLER MADSEN Head of Section, Chief of Defence Headquarters, Denmark Mr Andreos KINTIS Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Athens Mr Heinz KLUSS Director of the Defence and Security Committee North Atlantic Assembly, Brussels Mr Alexander KRETHLOW Political Analyst Swiss Federal Department of Defence, Bern Mrs Belen LARA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Bertrand de LARGENTAYE Charg de mission au Centre d'Analyse et Prvision, Ministre des Affaires trangres, France Mr Guido LENZI Director, WEU Institute for Security Studies, Paris Commander Fernando LISTA Aide de Camp to the Director of the WEU Planning Cell, Brussels Mr Jaime LOBO ASENJO Senador, Comisin de Defensa del Senado, Madrid Mr Martin LOCKHART Senior Fellow, Center for the Study of Democracy, Bulgaria Mr Jos Maria LOPEZ-NAVARRO Liaison Officer, Spain, NATO HQ Mr Antonio MARQUINA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Jordi MARSAL i MUNTALA Secretary of the Defence Committee, Member of the Asociacin Atlntica espanola, Spanish Chamber of Deputies, Madrid Mr Ral MARTIN Secretario, Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mrs Laura MARTINEZ BERENGUER Senador, Comisin de Defensa del Senado, Madrid Mr Alberto MINGUEZ Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid M. Bernard MOLARD Directeur, Centre satellitaire de l'UEO Torrejn, Spain Mr Sndor MOLNRI Deputy Head, Policy Planning, Analysis and Information Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Hungary Mr Rimantas MORKVENAS Head of Policy Planning Division Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Lithuania Mr Pedro MOYA Deputy, Former member of the WEU Assembly, Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Alejandro MUNOZ ALONSO Deputy, Vicepresidente Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Vladimir MLLER State Adminstrative Counsellor, Ministry of Defence, Czech Republic Mr Carlos NAVAJAS Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Martin ORTEGA Research Fellow, WEU Institute for Security Studies, Paris M. Gustavo PALLARES Conseiller du Prsident de l'Assemble parlementaire de l'OSCE, Chambre des Dputs, Madrid Mr Fernando PARDO de SANTAYANA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Gonzalo PARENTE + spouse Emeritus Professor CESEDEN, Madrid Mr Javier PEREZ-BOTIJA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Pawel PISKORSKI Member of Parliament, Member of the National Defence Committee, Sejm of the Republic of Poland, Warsaw Mr Fritz RADEMACHER Multilateral and Regional Affairs Division, NATO HQ Colonel Benito RAGGIO CACHINERO Plans and Policy Division, Chief of International Affairs Department, Madrid Mr Antonio REMIRO Director,Centro Espagnol de Relaciones Internacionales (CERI) Madrid Mr Josef RIBERA Director, Fundacio CIDOB, Madrid M. Eric ROCHAT Conseiller aux tats, Prsident de la Commission de la politique de scurit du Conseil des tats, Parlement suisse, Berne Mr Fernando RODRIGO Deputy Director, Centro Espagnol de Relaciones Internacionales (CERI) Madrid Mr Jos RODRIGUEZ-SPITERI Director General European and North American Political Affairs, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Madrid M. Domenico ROMANO CARRATELLI Membre de la commission de dfense, Chambre des Dputs, Italie Mr Jos Daniel ROMERO IGLESIAS Admiral, Plans Division, Spanish Navy Staff Headquarters, Madrid M. Javier RUPEREZ Prsident de la l'Assemble parlementaire de l'OSCE, Chambre des Dputs, Madrid Mr Felipe SAHAGN Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Fernando de SALAS LPEZ Rector de la Sociedad de Estudios Internacionales Madrid Mr Antxn SARASQUETA Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Carlos SEBASTIA CAMARASA Chief of Defence Organisations Section, Strategy and military cooperation division, Spanish Defence Joint Staff, Madrid Ambassador Maurizio SERRA Counsellor, Head of the Policy Planning Office Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Rome Mme Myriam SOCHACKI Chef du Bureau Presse et Information, Secrtariat Gnral de l'UEO, Bruxelles Mrs Elvira SANCHEZ MATEOS Head of Studies Fundaci CIDOB, Madrid Mr Felix SANZ ROLDAN Subdirector general de Asuntos Internacionales de Defensa Ministerio de Defensa, Madrid Mr Werner SCHAICH Counsellor, Desk for Security and Defence Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Germany Mr Hans SJBERG Assistant Director, Policy Planning, Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Sweden Sir Dudley SMITH Honorary Associate and former President of the WEU Assembly United Kingdom Colonel Karl E. TOOL, USA Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (Acquisition & Technology) Armaments Cooperation Atlantic, The Pentagon, Washington Excmo. Sr. D. Luis de TORRES GOMEZ Secretario Defensa del Congreso de los Diputados, Madrid M. Mirko TREMAGLIA Membre de la commission des affaires trangres, Chambre des Dputs, Italie Sr. Dn. Mariano UCELAY DE MONTERO Director Escuela Diplomtica, Madrid Mrs Silvia VALDES Asociacin Atlntica Espaola, Madrid Mr Josef VARELA SERRA Senador, Madrid Mr Jos M. VEIGA GARCIA Chief of NATO/WEU relations unit, Ministry of Defence, Madrid Mr Saverio VERTONE GRIMALDI Senator, Representing the Foreign Affairs Committee of the Italian Senate, Rome Interpreters Mrs Elonora CAMBAS (Greece) Mrs Cristina DI PIETRO (Italy) Mrs Rossella MESSINA (Italy) Mrs Fausta LIBARDI (Italy) Mrs Vicky NICOLOPOULOU (Greece) Secretariat of the Italian delegation Mr Federioc CASELLI Mrs Melina DECARO Mrs Enza PROIETTI BEFANI Accompanying Admiral Torrente, Min. Defence, Spain Mr BARDAJI Mrs RODRIGUEZ Accompanying Admiral Lopez, AFSOUTH Lieutenant Steve FAHEY, Special Assistant Captain Ken HEIMGARTNER, Executive Assistant Lieutenant Colonel Pierfranco MAIDA, Air Aide to CINCSOUTH Mr George MURPHY, Security Mr Mitchell SMITH, Security WEU Secretariat Mrs Caroline BARB, accueil Mrs Maureen BASSE, cabinet du Prsident, reprsentation et coordination accueil Mrs Kathrine BENCHEMAM, accueil MM Kilian BORTER, service de presse Eike BURCHARD, secrtaire de la commission politique Henri BURGELIN, greffier Mrs Indira BRISSET, traduction et actes du colloque MM Oscar CANHAM, coordination organisation Colin CAMERON, greffier adjoint Franco COLA, reprographie Floris DE GOU, secrtaire de la commission de dfense Roger LOUTZ, greffier adjoint Jos PEDREGOSA, secrtaire de la commission technique et arospatiale Mrs Mait REMISE, presse, accueil Mr Yves ROBINS, conseiller de presse Ms Christine TABAUD, traduction et actes du colloque Ms Isabel DE TARAZONA, accueil et liaison avec les autorits des Corts Mr Franciscos VERROS, secrtaire pays partenaires associs Mrs Franoise DU VILLARD, chef interprte Mrs Mary ZULKE-DENNETT, interprtation NATO Staff MM Paul MAGIS Christian SCHEURWEGHS